“Competitiveness, Carbon Leakage, and Border Tax Adjustments: Might Imperfect Competition Matter?”
نویسنده
چکیده
In this paper, analysis is presented relating to the impact of border tax adjustments for climate policy on the international competitiveness of energy-intensive industries, and the related problem of carbon leakage. While many of the economic and legal issues are not particularly new, climate policy does present some possible twists to the analysis of border tax adjustments when vertically-related markets can be characterized as a successive oligopoly. Specifically, an appropriate border tax adjustment will depend on the incidence of a domestic carbon tax, the nature of competition in upstream and downstream sectors, as well as the basis for assessing the trade neutrality of any border tax adjustment. If trade neutrality is defined in terms of market volume, even though carbon leakage is reduced, domestic firm competitiveness cannot be maintained. This compares to defining trade neutrality in terms of market share, which results in domestic competitiveness being maintained and global carbon emissions being reduced.
منابع مشابه
Border adjustments under unilateral carbon pricing: the case of Australian carbon tax
In the absence of a global agreement to reduce emissions, Australia has adopted a carbon tax unilaterally to curb its own emissions. During the debate prior to passing the carbon tax legislation, there were concerns about the challenge that Australia’s emissions intensive and trade exposed (EITE) industries may face in terms of decreasing international competitiveness due to the unilateral natu...
متن کاملEfficiency and Equity Implications of Alternative Instruments to Reduce Carbon Leakage
The cost-effectiveness of unilateral emission abatement can be seriously hampered by emission leakage. We assess three widely-discussed proposals for leakage reduction targeted at energyintensive and trade-exposed industries: border tax adjustments, output-based allocation and industry exemptions. We find that none of these measures amounts to a “magic bullet” when both efficiency and equity cr...
متن کاملIn the current session of Congress, a climate change bill sponsored by Representatives
In the current session of Congress, a climate change bill sponsored by Representatives Waxman and Markey was passed by the House in June 2009. 1 Part of this bill contains clear language that, in the absence of any multilateral agreement on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, the US should unilaterally implement border adjustments such as “carbon tariffs” for US domestic climate policy. The extent ...
متن کاملFrameworks for Evaluating Policy Approaches to Address the Competitiveness Concerns of Mitigating Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Domestic carbon pricing policies may impose adverse competitiveness risks on energy-intensive firms and industries competing with foreign firms that may bear a lower or zero price on carbon. The risks of competitiveness effects include adverse economic outcomes—reduced production, lower employment, and higher net imports—and adverse environmental outcomes, with the shifting of emissions-intensi...
متن کاملAnalysis of Carbon Leakage in an Extended Ricardo-Viner Model
Carbon leakage remains a topic of crucial importance as long as the international climate regime remains fragmented. In the first part of this paper, we adopt a typology of three distinct channels of carbon leakage and use it as a guide to review the existing literature. In the second part, we investigate the interplay of two forms of leakage, namely specialisation leakage (linked to termsof-tr...
متن کامل